| Date | Score | Most Valuable Players |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| January 15, 1939 | New York Giants 13 Pro All-Stars 10 |
No Selection | |
| January 14, 1940 | Green Bay Packers 16 NFL All-Stars 7 |
No Selection | |
| December 29, 1940 | Chicago Bears 28 NFL All-Stars 14 |
No Selection | |
| January 4, 1942 | Chicago Bears 35 NFL All-Stars 24 |
No Selection | |
| December 27, 1942 | NFL All-Stars 17 Washington Redskins 14 |
No Selection | |
| 1943-50 - No games | |||
| January 14, 1951 | American Conference 28 National Conference 27 |
Otto Graham, Cleveland Browns | |
| January 12, 1952 | National Conference 30 American Conference 13 |
Dan Towler, Los Angeles Rams | |
| January 10, 1953 | National Conference 27 American Conference 7 |
Don Doll, Detroit Lions | |
| January 17, 1954 | East 20, West 9 | Chuck Bednarik, Philadelphia Eagles | |
| January 16, 1955 | West 26, East 19 | Billy Wilson, San Francisco 49ers | |
| January 15, 1956 | East 31, West 30 | Ollie Matson, Chicago Cardinals | |
| January 13, 1957 | West 19, East 10 | Bert Rechichar, Baltimore Colts Ernie Stautner, Pittsburgh Steelers |
|
| January 12, 1958 | West 26, East 7 | Hugh McElhenny, San Francisco 49ers Gene Brito, Washington Redskins |
|
| January 11, 1959 | East 28, West 21 | Frank Gifford, New York Giants Doug Atkins, Chicago Bears |
|
| January 17, 1960 | West 38, East 21 | Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts Eugene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb, Pittsburgh Steelers |
|
| January 15, 1961 | West 35, East 31 | Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts Sam Huff, New York Giants |
|
| January 14, 1962 | West 31, East 30 | Jim Brown, Cleveland Browns Henry Jordan, Green Bay Packers |
|
| January 13, 1963 | East 30, West 20 | Jim Brown, Cleveland Browns Eugene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb, Pittsburgh Steelers |
|
| January 12, 1964 | West 31, East 17 | Johnny Unitas, Baltimore Colts Gino Marchetti, Baltimore Colts |
|
| January 10, 1965 | West 34, East 14 | Fran Tarkenton, Minnesota Vikings Terry Barr, Detroit Lions |
|
| January 15, 1966 | East 36, West 7 | Jim Brown, Cleveland Browns Dale Meinhart, St. Louis Cardinals |
|
| January 22, 1967 | East 20, West 10 | Gale Sayers, Chicago Bears Floyd Peters, Philadelphia Eagles |
|
| January 21, 1968 | West 38, East 20 | Gale Sayers, Chicago Bears Dave Robinson, Green Bay Packers |
|
| January 19, 1969 | West 10, East 7 | Roman Gabriel, Los Angeles Rams Merlin Olsen, Los Angeles Rams |
|
| January 18, 1970 | West 16, East 13 | Gale Sayers, Chicago Bears George Andrie, Cowboys |
|
| January 24, 1971 | NFC, 27-6 | Mel Renfro, Dallas Cowboys Fred Carr, Green Bay Packers |
|
| January 23, 1972 | AFC, 26-13 | Jan Stenerud, Kansas City Chiefs Willie Lanier, Kansas City Chiefs |
|
| January 21, 1973 | AFC, 33-28 | O.J. Simpson, Buffalo Bills | |
| January 20, 1974 | AFC, 15-13 | Garo Yepremian, Miami Dolphins | |
| January 20, 1975 | NFC, 17-10 | James Harris, Los Angeles Rams | |
| January 26, 1976 | NFC, 23-20 | Billy Johnson, Houston Oilers | |
| January 17, 1977 | AFC, 24-14 | Mel Blount, Pittsburgh Steelers | |
| January 23, 1978 | NFC, 14-13 | Walter Payton, Chicago Bears | |
| January 29, 1979 | NFC, 13-7 | Ahmad Rashad, Minnesota Vikings | |
| January 27, 1980 | NFC, 37-27 | Chuck Muncie, New Orleans Saints | |
| February 1, 1981 | NFC, 21-7 | Eddie Murray, Detroit Lions | |
| January 31, 1982 | AFC, 16-13 | Kellen Winslow, San Diego Chargers Lee Roy Selmon, Tampa Bay Buccaneers |
|
| February 6, 1983 | NFC, 20-19 | Dan Fouts, San Diego Chargers John Jefferson, Green Bay Packers |
|
| January 29, 1984 | NFC, 45-3 | Joe Theismann, Washington Redskins | |
| January 27, 1985 | AFC, 22-14 | Mark Gastineau, New York Jets | |
| February 2, 1986 | NFC, 28-24 | Phil Simms, New York Giants | |
| February 1, 1987 | AFC, 10-6 | Reggie White, Philadelphia Eagles | |
| February 7, 1988 | AFC, 15-6 | Bruce Smith, Buffalo Bills | |
| January 29, 1989 | NFC, 34-3 | Randall Cunningham, Philadelphia Eagles | |
| February 4, 1990 | NFC, 27-21 | Jerry Gray, Los Angeles Rams | |
| February 3, 1991 | AFC, 23-21 | Jim Kelly, Buffalo Bills | |
| February 2, 1992 | NFC, 21-15 | Michael Irvin, Dallas Cowboys | |
| February 7, 1993 | AFC, 23-20 (OT) | Steve Tasker, Buffalo Bills | |
| February 6, 1994 | NFC, 17-3 | Andre Rison, Atlanta Falcons | |
| February 5, 1995 | AFC, 41-13 | Marshall Faulk, Indianapolis Colts | |
| February 4, 1996 | NFC, 20-13 | Jerry Rice, San Francisco 49ers | |
| February 2, 1997 | AFC, 26-23 (OT) | Mark Brunell, Jacksonville Jaguars | |
| February 1, 1998 | AFC, 29-24 | Warren Moon, Seattle Seahawks | |
| February 7, 1999 | AFC, 23-10 | Ty Law, New England Patriots Keyshawn Johnson, New York Jets |
|
| February 6, 2000 | NFC, 51-31 | Randy Moss, Minnesota Vikings | |
| February 4, 2001 | AFC, 38-17 | Rich Gannon, Oakland Raiders | |
| February 10, 2002 | AFC, 38-30 | Rich Gannon, Oakland Raiders | |
| February 2, 2003 | AFC, 45-20 | Ricky Williams, Miami Dolphins | |
| February 8, 2004 | NFC, 55-52 | Marc Bulger, St. Louis Rams | |
| February 13, 2005 | AFC, 38-27 | Peyton Manning, Indianapolis Colts | |
| February 12, 2006 | NFC 23-17 | Derrick Brooks, Tampa Bay Buccaneers | |
| February 10, 2007 | AFC 31-28 | Carson Palmer, Cincinnati Bengals | |
| February 10, 2008 | NFC 42-30 | Adrian Peterson, Minnesota Vikings | |
| February 9, 2009 | NFC 20-19 | Larry Fitzgerald, Arizona Cardinals | |
| January 31, 2010 | AFC 41-34 | Matt Schaub, Houston Texans | |
| January 30, 2011 | AFC 55-41 | DeAngelo Hall, Washington Redskins | |
| January 29, 2012 | AFC 59-41 | Brandon Marshall, Miami Dolphins | |
| January 27, 2013 | NFC 62-35 | Kyle Rudolph, Minnesota Vikings | |
| January 26, 2014 | Team Rice 22 Team Sanders 21 |
Offense: Nick Foles, Philadelphia Eagles
Defense: Derrick Johnson, Kansas City Chiefs |
|
| January 25, 2015 | Team Irvin 32 Team Carter 28 |
Offense: Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions
Defense: J. J. Watt, Houston Texans |
|
| January 31, 2016 | Team Irvin 49 Team Rice 27 |
Offense: Russell Wilson, Seahawks
Defense: Michael Bennett, Seahawks |
|
| January 29, 2017 | AFC 20 NFC 13 |
Offense: Travis Kelce, Kansas City Chiefs
Defense: Lorenzo Alexander, Buffalo Bills |
|
| January 28, 2018 | AFC 24 NFC 23 |
Offense: Delanie Walker, Tennessee Titans
Von Miller, Denver Broncos |
|
| January 27, 2019 | AFC 26 NFC 7 |
Offense: Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City Chiefs
Defensive: Jamal Adams, New York Jets |
|
| January 26, 2020 | AFC 38 NFC 33 |
Offensive: Lamar Jackson, Baltimore Ravens
Defensive: Calais Campbell, Jacksonville Jaguars |
|
| January 31, 2021 | |
|
|